Owners of a new clothing store in India called "Hitler" agreed to
change their business’s name after public outrage and pressure from local government,
BBC reports.
The owners claim they had opened the store with no knowledge
of who Adolf Hitler was or what he was responsible for. Co-owner Manish
Chandani said the name had been given to his grandfather, who was known for
being “strict.”
If that’s true (not very hard to believe), societies
at large need to reconsider their approach to educating people about the
Holocaust and the rise of Fascism in Germany. Many people flat out don’t know a
thing about either. Worse yet, many don’t believe it!
Last semester, I wrote a HIS 285 research paper on
the Holocaust Denial Movement. I learned it was larger and more influential
than I had thought. It was really disgusting stuff that I think society needs
to be aware of and ready to counter.
However, the owners could have known about Hitler
and they just wanted to spark controversy (Not very hard to believe either).
Questions for Reader
At what age did you learn about the atrocities of
Nazi Germany? How do you think educators should go about delivering a scholarly
education on the subject especially to young people?
Let’s say such a store popped up in America. Should
said person be allowed to exercise his right to call his business whatever he wants
and let consumers decide whether to support his business? In this case, why
would thorough knowledge of Nazi Germany be important?

I don't remember when I learned about Nazi Germany and what happened but I do believe it happened. Truthfully I think the education on the subject will depend on the type of school and how young the subject would be introduced.
ReplyDeleteIf such a store did appear in America, although the owners would be free to name it whatever they wanted, it does not mean that the business will last. The public would cause a protest, especially with our large and diverse population.
As far as the hypothetical American "Hitler" store. I agree with Krystina that I think it would be allowed, but it would be up to the popular market to decide if it would become successful enough to remain open.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't find anything specific on the web, but I would wonder if there exists any profanity or offensive laws in the United States to keep someone from opening a store named "FUCK" on Main Street in a small town.
Personally, I'm of the mindset that words and words and you give them more power only when you react to them. If Hitler was regarded in the same way as the word bridge or something, then no one would have a problem, nor would a story be able to profit off the controversy of their unusual name.
In the end, words are just a series of symbols to represent objects and concepts. Hitler is no more dangerous of a word than a series of random icons "&*!^@"
As far as when I first learned about Nazi Germany. It was likely in mid-to-late elementary school. While I can imagine a smaller, east asian township not having World War II as part of the curriculum, I cannot see the residents of more urbanized areas of India having the same excuse.
Even the fact that the grandfather was nicknamed "Hitler" because he was strict seems like a stretch. It would be like nicknaming your grandfather "Einstein" because he was smart and not realizing who "Einstein" was.
I agree that people decide much of what any word means. Think of politicians and how they demonize their opponents by calling them "Facsists," "Socialists," "Bigots" or "Nazis" without responsibly backing up their claims.
DeleteThe business obviously knew what they were getting themselves into. Who puts a swastika on their "i" without realizing that it's a demeaning symbol all throughout the world?
ReplyDeleteAs for India being the one to have such a store, I absolutely believe that since they have the highest population in the world, it is possible that many don't know who Hitler is. Especially since they weren't part of the war at all or subjected to killings as were the Jews were, it's probably not labeled in their textbooks or spread throughout their educational system that Hitler was a bad person or heard through colleagues and friends that the rest of the world feels hate towards him.
This reminds me of a real story from a couple of years ago when a couple wanted to name their baby Hitler Aryan Smith (Not sure what last name was). The actually weren't allowed to do it. Courts intervened and said they couldn't do it.
ReplyDelete